In brief
- Retained foreign bodies pose a serious patient safety risk, resulting in significant physical, and sometimes psychological, harm.
- Preventing retained foreign bodies during surgery—most often sponges but also other instruments—requires multiple safeguards and is a shared responsibility of the surgical team.
- Standardized surgical counts and use of the Surgical Safety Checklist in Canada are aimed at helping to prevent retained foreign bodies during surgery.
- Following hospital policies and procedures and fostering psychological safety in the OR can further help mitigate the risk.
Case scenario: A sponge remains inside a patient despite multiple attempts to locate it
A patient with L2-L3 disc herniation is undergoing a microdiscectomy. The team encounters bleeding from the epidural veins, and the surgeon controls it using cottonoid patties. At the end of surgery, the nurse announces a discrepancy in the sponge count. The surgeon visually inspects the operative field using a microscope but cannot see the patty; he concludes that it must have been caught in the drapes. Once the incision is closed, the team orders a portable intra-operative X-ray as per protocol when the count is incorrect. The surgeon reviews the X-ray image and sees no evidence of the patty. He files an incident report. Days later, a radiologist notes a small radio-opaque area on the film—possibly a retained sponge. However, the surgeon does not receive the radiologist’s report.
With chronic pain months later, the patient initiates a civil legal action against the surgeon for failing to locate and remove the patty intra-operatively. Peer expert reviewers in the case note that the patty was easily visible on the intra-operative X-ray film. The patient receives a settlement from the CMPA on behalf of the surgeon for failing to identify the patty and from the hospital for failing to deliver the radiology report.
How can the surgical team enhance patient safety?
The case scenario illustrates that there are often various contributing factors leading to unintentional retention of foreign objects.
The risk of such events may be reduced by:
- ensuring post-operative orders are clear
- using radiographic imaging in some circumstances
- augmenting the surgical count with technologies such as radiofrequency tags and wands
- fostering a culture of psychological safety that encourages all team members to effectively communicate and speak up
1. Use more than one strategy for prevention
Although manual surgical counts, methodical wound exploration, and radiographic imaging are all accepted strategies for prevention, the case scenario shows that each step on its own can be prone to error. Prevention therefore needs multiple layers of protection, with each layer optimized. Augmented or supplemental strategies may help. In the case scenario, for example—when there was no clear reason for the discrepant count—it may have been possible for the neurosurgeon to augment the X-ray protocol by contacting a radiologist for a second opinion before closing.
Post-operative orders and discharge summaries should be clear
Certain items, such wound packing, are purposefully left in by the surgical team. As a surgeon communicating to the post-operative care team, be explicit in your instructions on what to replace or remove. To avoid misunderstandings, distinguish between “packing” inside the wound and “dressing” on top of the wound.
Similarly, discharge summaries should be clear and complete to provide the information home care providers may need to provide continued patient care.
2. Consider whether radiographic imaging is required when the risk of a retained foreign body is high
Certain operative factors, including patients with increased body mass index, urgent or unplanned procedures, high-volume blood loss, and nursing shift changes may increase the possibility of a retained foreign body. Assess the need for radiographic imaging when these or other risk factors are present.
3. Consider other options to augment the surgical count
Radiofrequency tags and wands (for tracking and locating retained items) and bar codes (for tracking items before and after surgery) are options to augment the surgical count and potentially reduce the need for intra-operative X-rays. These technologies, however, are only one layer of protection intended to complement, rather than replace, other modalities.
4. Foster psychological safety
When team members are reluctant to speak up, OR prevention strategies may be less effective. In the case scenario, for example, it is conceivable that the nurse thought it prudent to obtain a radiologist’s interpretation of the X-ray film, but did not express that opinion out of fear of being ridiculed or ignored.
To foster psychological safety, reflect on how to create the best conditions for teams to speak up, and be open and encouraging when a team member voices concern about a missing item. Engage consistently during the Surgical Safety Checklist, and minimize distractions to show you are engaged in the importance of this safety procedure.
The surgical count should be given undivided attention
Mitigate the impact of interruptions and distractions in the OR. Consider a formal pause for the surgical count before closing, as is policy in some institutions.
More reading